Railway Forum

Railway Forum (https://www.railwayforum.net/index.php)
-   Say Hello (https://www.railwayforum.net/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Do you want to feature in a documentary? (https://www.railwayforum.net/showthread.php?t=9308)

basementdocumentary 6th March 2011 22:31

Do you want to feature in a documentary?
 
Hello,

My name is Joel Stocker and I am the producer of media production company BasementDocumentary. We are 2nd year BA (hons) Media Productions students studying at The University of Winchester undertaking a yearlong module in documentary film.

One of our current projects is about trainspotters and rail enthusiasts as we try to challenge the stereotype and discover where the passion for trains comes from. I would very much like to work alongside people, like yourselves, to achieve this goal as I feel you would be paramount to us producing a brilliant documentary that we will be entering into competition in June.

If you require more validation of my intent please feel free to contact my supervising lecturer, who will verify the intentions of our project.

Supervising lecturer: Mr Karin Stowe BA (Hons), MA, PGCE/FE
Office Telephone number: 01962 827206
Email: HYPERLINK "mailto:[email protected]" [email protected]

Yours sincerely,

Joel Stocker
Tel: 07804105408
Email: [email protected]

Belmont Road 7th March 2011 09:13

The term train spotters always arouses concerns. In the wider context it is often used as a derogatory lable.

The term "Rail Buffs" also can be used to ridicule. A typical newspaper line that I have often seen is "Rail buffs get all steamed up about new train" etc etc.

It would also seem that similar lables are applied in the USA too, but less so in continental Europe.

Good luck in trying to unpack this one. It may stem from the 1960's when both here and in the USA rail seemed to be in terminal decline and those supporting it were seen as a rather weird and out of touch with "progress".

Rail was better regarded elsewhere in Europe so not the same stigma perhaps???

bramleyman 7th March 2011 22:14

Okay, so when I was first interested in trains, then I was a train-spotter, but now I am a lot older, so I feel better being classed as a Rail Enthusiast.

pre65 7th March 2011 23:43

I don't take numbers any more, and prefer to be called a "railway enthusiast".:D

basementdocumentary 8th March 2011 10:22

This is all good advice guys.

But I need to know if any one of you would be willing to get involved with our documentary. Our intention is to create an observational documentary that challenges the social stereotype and judgmental opinions upheld by some of the public about rail enthusiasts.
We intend for it to be a documentary in which the story is told by the subjects and not the filmmakers. This means that at no point will we (the production team) be on camera. Our reasons for doing this is to create a ‘fly on the wall’ type scenario allowing the viewer a window into the lives of our subjects.

We are heading up to Swindon and Cricklade railway who have agreed to let us film up there during the weekends. So anyone who gets involved can enjoy that experience with us.

Madcaravanner 8th March 2011 11:57

I was interested but with all the responses from the forum there has been no response from the OP so have we got a troll???

Belmont Road 8th March 2011 12:51

I have been on the media with regard to rail issues when I worked for the Rail Passenger's Committee for Southern England, now replaced by Passenger Focus.

To be on the Media requires training especially if you are representing a cause. I think your idea of using subjects only would probably not be entirely effective. I might be interested if you were to consider another model i.e. with professional input in the presentation.

StoneRoad 8th March 2011 21:53

been there, done that, "starred in the film"

so, thanks, but no thanks! as I don't think the production I took part in had any affect at all, despite being re-played on TV/satellite several times.....

sorry.......

and winchester is a bit too far from my current base.

bramleyman 8th March 2011 23:47

While I wouldn't mind taking part, at present I am unable to arrange anything, as my Wife is currently in need of me here, due to a Serious Health problem she is going through, following a Doctor from our local surgery REFUSING to come out when first summonsed in early February, because as HE claimed, HE was the Only Doctor out of the 3 that are normally on duty, and available.

He showed how concerned he was, by phoning us 36 hours LATER, offering to see my wife, but only AFTER she had been sent home from hospital, because of his refusal to attend her until many hours later.
:mad::mad::mad:

37057 10th March 2011 11:09

Hello and welcome to the forum! :)

redudley 12th March 2011 11:25

Documentary
 
Their seems to be a lot of negative response to this request by basementdocumentary.
Why is this? Are we ashamed of our hobby, or is it because we trainspotters/railway enthusiast
have been ridiculed so much over the years and are frightened to put our heads above the wall.
Seeing my first engine, was like falling in love for the first time, it was something you would never forget.
I chased after numbers, but how many hobbies took you all over the country teaching you all the time. Yes, we broke the law on occasions, by just being in sheds without permission, our only motive
being to get those numbers.
So come on tell your stories and be proud that you had a hobby and an education that has lasted a lifetime.

Belmont Road 12th March 2011 12:28

Quote:

Originally Posted by redudley (Post 59432)
Their seems to be a lot of negative response to this request by basementdocumentary.
Why is this? Are we ashamed of our hobby, or is it because we trainspotters/railway enthusiast
have been ridiculed so much over the years and are frightened to put our heads above the wall.
Seeing my first engine, was like falling in love for the first time, it was something you would never forget.
I chased after numbers, but how many hobbies took you all over the country teaching you all the time. Yes, we broke the law on occasions, by just being in sheds without permission, our only motive
being to get those numbers.
So come on tell your stories and be proud that you had a hobby and an education that has lasted a lifetime.

I agree with this all the way. But perhaps the format offered to us was a little vague. I have sent a personal message to thread originator but have not received a reply yet.

Madcaravanner 13th March 2011 15:25

I started out positively........................


I have already had one film crew filming my model railway and they were as enthusiastic as me at the end of 5 minutes they were kids again

basementdocumentary 24th March 2011 21:34

Hey guys, we're really sorry I haven't been in touch or replying. We've been rather busy with other film projects we are undertaking. We are back on track nevertheless.

We're not a 'troll' we are serious film makers wanting to find out more, just give us time!

Thanks for all the responses you've given us, in the next few days we'll follow up any correspondence we wish to take further.

Thanks again and sorry for the lack of communication!

BasementDocumentary.

Madcaravanner 25th March 2011 12:31

Well I withdraw my comment

I was saying that as a Railway enthusiast who tries to model to a high standard (still learning scratch building) a lot of my time is taken up researching railway establishments and photographing buildings and trackside hardware even though I do still take numbers of loco's, coaches (when we see any), and wagons (when they are clean enough to see -Freightliner clean your stock please)

I am willing to discuss what your needs are compared to my needs before I commit to any thing being filmed


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 16:56.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.