Performance of Type 5 Loco`s ?
 

Just a bit of a Competition !!
A few Years ago a series of trials were done with Type 5 Loco`s at EWS.
Identical loads (34 MGR loaded ) from a standing start on identical weather and rail conditions.
Loco types were :--
Class 56
Class58
Class59
Class60
Class66
At a distance of around 3 Miles a speed reading was taken !!!!
Which order do you think the loco`s Finished in ???
Kris
Have a guess !!

here's my guess

58
56
60
59
66

Just random, though you way you frame the question suggest a surprising answer.
why the accent on loco´s?!

A Deltic would have beat the lot.:p:rolleyes:
Yes even with freight.

Oh Dear Bubblewrap !!
It would not have come close !! even if it is a Great Express loco !!
Kris

meurglys !! I will let ya know in a few days
:)
Kris

MMM
I once read the 59 was the best ever so my guess is
59
60
66
58
56

I will go with

60
59
66
58
56

Cheers Guys !! & also Thanks Very Much.
I will post the results Mid day Tuesday.
There is a Token Prize !! Nothing much but just a bit of something for your thoughts.
I wouldn`t have got it right by the way !!
Regards
Kris

58
66
56
59
60

Thanks Guys for posting on this. No one got it 100% right and if I had to guess prior to the tests I would have got it wrong.
The result was ---- ( Drumroll !!! lol )
1st -- Class 58
2nd -- Class59/2
3rd -- Class56
4th -- Class60
5th -- Class66

I personally fully expected the Class59/2 to be the fastest at the point where the speed/timing readings were taken.
I don`t really think it proves anything as so many variables exist, such as the variance within type of the 56/58 regarding performance. The G.M Locos are pretty much a fairly standard performer across the Class`s as is the 60.
If the Rail head conditions had been wet instead of dry the I`m pretty sure the 58 would have finished last with the 56 not much ahead of it and the 59/2 1st and either 60/66 2nd.
Regards & Thanks
Kris

The main criteria would be the gearing chosen for each loco,I would have expected the class 60 to be lower geared than the 66.

Thanks Saltley Seagull.
The 60 I would think is probably lower geared ( although I am no expert in gear ratios) and with a max speed of 60mph versus the 66 with 75mph that would suggest you are right.
The 60 is a real strong work horse type with a wonderful plodder style of acceleration but once up there just keeps going at a nice rate of knots.
Its one failing is perhaps its reliability record.
Regards
Kris

{/QUOTE}
The 60 is a real strong work horse type with a wonderful plodder style of acceleration but once up there just keeps going at a nice rate of knots.
Its one failing is perhaps its reliability record.
Regards
Kris[/QUOTE]

Reliability is down to two things age of these locos plus bad maintenance,most of the fleet should have had an "F" exam years ago !

I actually love the Class 60 but even from "New" they have not been able to compete with the General Motors Loco`s in terms of Reliability.
I remember from coming out of the "works" the Loco`s engines leaked oil.
The Electrical system was overly complex.
Governors having problems due to heat from the Engine
Exploding Turbo Chargers !
Compared to the Class 60`s direct competitor the Class 59 with its Basic Technology on reliability and performance has always had an advantage.
As you state Maintainance is a very large Factor in the equation of reliability / availability and knowing the "Regimes" of Mendip & National Power the reliability figures are no real suprise.
Regards
Kris

the 59 class being a very small fleet on dedicated traffic flows makes it easier to maintain and plan maintenance than a fleet of 100 class 60 loco's dispersed allover the BR system on varied types of traffic and the need to keep them in traffic for as long as possible each day.As regards overheating of "Governors" this was caused primarily by the inner doors between the engine and "clean air compartment" having the habit of being "sucked" open whilst working the loco hard.Although I know liitle about class 59s but drove class 60s from their introduction through to my retirement as a Driver at Saltley,I can only say that they were a superb loco to work with and until the last couple of years that I worked on them I had very little trouble in the way of failures.

my guess........:)

60
56
59
58
66

Are there any 59"s still on workings anywere??