Railway Forum

Railway Forum (https://www.railwayforum.net/index.php)
-   Diesel & Electric Discussion (https://www.railwayforum.net/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   Class 40 (https://www.railwayforum.net/showthread.php?t=12500)

wyvern 7th August 2013 09:57

Class 40
 
I saw the item on the BBC this morning about the Great Train Robbery and D326 which featured in tha accompanying visuals.

I dint know any Type 4 diesels had steam whistles?

:D

pre65 7th August 2013 10:10

Neither did I.:eek:

They were fitted with boilers for train heating, but I'm fairly certain they had 2 tone air horns.

wyvern 7th August 2013 15:33

Guess the post-editing sound bloke wasnt very clued up.

Silver Fox Phil 7th August 2013 16:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by pre65 (Post 77341)
Neither did I.:eek:

They were fitted with boilers for train heating, but I'm fairly certain they had 2 tone air horns.

Sounds about right to me too!
Cheers
Phil

Madcaravanner 7th August 2013 19:12

1 Attachment(s)
Class 40 had two tone horns in the nose -check the grills on the photo
Yes the had steam heat boilers as all mainline loco's did then

the only type of loco that I am aware with whistles are Shunters (08/09/10/12etc) but a diesel whistle sounds nothing like a steam one

wyvern 7th August 2013 20:47

I wonder if I can get a copy of the film to link you to.

keith morgan 7th August 2013 20:50

I have posted this observation in the book section already, i watched an old film the other week (not a railway film) it shows a train leaving Paddington behind a "Castle" then the train at speed behind a Royal Scot on the WCML, the next scene ------ train arriving in York!!! i wonder who researched that journey.

springs branch mickey 9th August 2013 09:12

The one thing that bugged me in the past, was the lack of railway knowledge, when making films. Wrong locomotive class, sometimes even wrong country, wrong era etc.
the films, documentaries were sometimes very good, but that little extra research would have made them better still.
mickey

Madcaravanner 9th August 2013 17:43

Quote:

Originally Posted by springs branch mickey (Post 77359)
The one thing that bugged me in the past, was the lack of railway knowledge, when making films. Wrong locomotive class, sometimes even wrong country, wrong era etc.
the films, documentaries were sometimes very good, but that little extra research would have made them better still.
mickey

I'm not going to defend filmmakers who get their continuity wrong but it happens even now what the Michael Portillo series and see the different trains supposedly the same train that he's on

it's just sloppy workmanship

Master Cutler 10th August 2013 07:49

On Thursday there I saw two Class 40's in convoy going north on the M1.
Thet looked like a couple of the ones from Clapham Junction.
Problem was I was going south so could only clock the graffiti on the side of the locos.
Does anyone know where they were bound for?
I can't find anything on the Class 40 Preservation Society web site.

chuffchuff 10th August 2013 10:36

Quote:

Originally Posted by Master Cutler (Post 77370)
On Thursday there I saw two Class 40's in convoy going north on the M1.
Thet looked like a couple of the ones from Clapham Junction.
Problem was I was going south so could only clock the graffiti on the side of the locos.
Does anyone know where they were bound for?
I can't find anything on the Class 40 Preservation Society web site.

Might be the two 37's that left Dollands Moor and were parked overnight at South Mimms. I think they were going to Barrow Hill

http://www.flickr.com/photos/stevestrains/7808403834/

Master Cutler 10th August 2013 11:13

Quote:

Originally Posted by chuffchuff (Post 77374)
Might be the two 37's that left Dollands Moor and were parked overnight at South Mimms. I think they were going to Barrow Hill

http://www.flickr.com/photos/stevestrains/7808403834/

Many thanks, that explains it, perhaps a visit to BH is on the cards.

Madcaravanner 11th August 2013 15:33

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by chuffchuff (Post 77374)
Might be the two 37's that left Dollands Moor and were parked overnight at South Mimms. I think they were going to Barrow Hill

http://www.flickr.com/photos/stevestrains/7808403834/


If they were Light Blue with a Dark Blue Stripe I can report that they are indeed at Barrow Hill 37 314 - 37703

meurglysIII 11th August 2013 19:58

In the TV series Hannibal, set in the US, they briefly used a clip of two HSTs at a station!

Also in the UK series with Sheridan Smith (think it was called Mr Biggs) about the "Great Train Robbery" they used a class 25! sloppy.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 18:19.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.